Christmas Cookies 2010

Slightly crunchy outside. Slightly chewy inside. Walnut atmosphere permeates. Fresh raisins.4 out of 5 *

Shortbread Marzipan Ring with Strawberry Centre

Melts in mouth. Too sweet for manly palette. Strawberry overcome by sweet shortbread. Lovely presentation (classy icing).3 out of 5Surprise Guest Review"Good. 4 out of 5."Guest reviews do not affect score.

Poppy Seed Glaze Coated Moon

Pleasant taste but can't place it. Despite appearance, it's light. Not too sweet - is that lemon? What is that? It's good.3.5 out of 5

Crouching Pac Man, Yellow Icing

Biggest crunch thus far. Thin. Packs compact taste punch. Lemon icing hits. Mmmmmmmm. Then it's over. Bonus for theme.3.5 out of 5

Tons of tasty chocolate chips. Cookie taste lost in explosion of raisins and chocolate.3.5 out of 5 but...ControversyAte and reviewed this cookie earlier. See "Chocolate Raisin Walnut Mound" 4 out of 5. Credibility in question. Final: 3.75 out of 5

Straight Chocolate Chip

The holy trinity: Chewy, Crunchy, Chocolatey. Supreme cookie taste. Original? No. Tasty? YES4 out of 5

Icing Splattered Walnut Island

Sublime taste. Digging those walnut bits. Exciting when I tasted icing... then boring.3 out of 5

Lonely Walnut Island

Tastes similar to above, except with more walnut bits. Still digging those walnut bits. Exciting when I tasted icing... WAIT... there's no icing.2.5 out of 5

Hypnotic Organic Spiral

Mean baked buttery taste. Icing provides kinky counterbalance. Stealth poppyseeds? Nice.3.5 out of 5

Outmeal Raisin Blotch

There's walnuts in these hills. Fills mouth like bread. Tasty, serious, not too sweet. Felt healthy. Had two.4 out of 5

Chocolate Dipped Coconut Pyramid

Risking marriage. Coconut texture impressive. Coconut + chocolate = awesome! Plain coconut depressing. Handsomest. Icing snowflake coup de grace.3.75 out of 5